Governance
Summary
Blockchains are distributed systems. They are essentially consensus protocols, which means that different nodes in the network (e.g. computers on the internet) have to be running compatible software.
“Node operators” are the owners and managers of nodes that run the protocol. Most node operators don’t want to write much software, and it’s a technical challenge for anyone to independently write compatible implementations of any consensus protocol even if they have a specification. As a result, node operators rely on software repositories (usually hosted on Microsoft/Github servers) to provide them with the software they choose to run.
“Core developers” of a blockchain are software developers who work on the software that implement that protocol. Developers have processes that are supposed to assure the quality of the software they release, and are generally very interested in maintaining the legitimacy of their software repositories because they want to see people using their software (as opposed to someone else’s).
Critical Components of Governance
1. Incentives
Each group in the system has their own incentives. Those incentives are not always 100% aligned with all other groups in the system. Groups will propose changes over time which are advantageous for them. Organisms are biased towards their own survival. This commonly manifests in changes to the reward structure, monetary policy, or balances of power.
2. Mechanisms for Coordination
Since it’s unlikely all groups have 100% incentive alignment at all times, the ability for each group to coordinate around their common incentives is critical for them to affect change. If one group can coordinate better than another, it creates power imbalances in their favor.
In practice, a major factor is how much coordination can be done on-chain vs. off-chain, where on-chain coordination makes coordinating easier. In some new blockchains (such as Tezos or Polkadot), on-chain coordination allows the rules or even the ledger history itself to be changed.
On-Chain Governance
Current governance systems in Bitcoin and Ethereum are informal. They were designed using a decentralized ethos, first promulgated by Satoshi Nakamoto in his original paper. Improvement proposals to make changes to the blockchain are submitted by developers and a core group, consisting mostly of developers, is responsible for coordinating and achieving consensus between stakeholders. The stakeholders in this case are miners (who operate nodes), developers (who are responsible for core blockchain algorithms) and users (who use and invest in various coins).
What is on-chain governance?
On-chain governance is a system for managing and implementing changes to cryptocurrency blockchains. In this type of governance, rules for instituting changes are encoded into the blockchain protocol. Developers propose changes through code updates and each node votes on whether to accept or reject the proposed change.
How does it work?
Unlike informal governance systems, which use a combination of offline coordination and online code modifications to effect changes, on-chain governance systems solely work online. Changes to a blockchain are proposed through code updates. Subsequently, nodes can vote to accept or decline the change. Not all nodes have equal voting power. Nodes with greater holdings of coins have more votes as compared to nodes that have a relatively lesser number of holdings.
If the change is accepted, it is included in the blockchain and baselined. In some instances of on-chain governance implementation, the updated code may be rolled back to its version before a baseline, if the proposed change is unsuccessful.
Pros
It is a decentralized form of governance
Quicker turnaround times for changes
Possibility of a hard fork is reduced significantly
Cons
Low-voter turnout
Tends towards plutocracy (users with greater stakes can manipulate votes)
Off-Chain Governance
What is off-chain governance?
Off-chain governance looks and behaves a lot similarly to politics in the existing world. Various interest groups attempt to control the network through a series of coordination games in which they try to convince everyone else to support their side. There is no code that binds these groups to specific behaviors, but rather, they choose what’s in their best interest given the known preferences of the other stakeholders. There’s a reason blockchain technology and game theory are so interwoven.
How does it work?
Improvement proposals to make changes to the blockchain are submitted by developers and a core group, consisting mostly of developers, is responsible for coordinating and achieving consensus between stakeholders. The stakeholders in this case are miners (who operate nodes), developers (who are responsible for core blockchain algorithms) and users (who use and invest in various coins).
The various stakeholders signal their approval or disapproval for an improvement proposal through private and community discourse. Then, the core developers get a sense for whether or not node operators and miners will agree to upgrade their software. Ideally, all sides agree and the code changes are made smoothly. Everything is announced beforehand and stakeholders have time to update.
In the case of disagreement, stakeholders have two options. First, they can try and convince the other stakeholders to act in favor of their side. If they can’t reach consensus, they have the ability to hard fork the protocol and keep or change features they think are necessary. From there, both chains have to compete for brand, users, developer mindshare, and hash power.
I think it’s instructive to look at Satoshi’s ANN thread on the Cryptography newsgroup/mailing list; particularly the various early criticisms:bitcoin xt wikileaks bitcoin bitcoin land coins bitcoin
bitcoin торги
linux bitcoin блок bitcoin
digi bitcoin car bitcoin 1 bitcoin bitcoin x2 перевод bitcoin отзывы ethereum bitcoin математика 2016 bitcoin rpc bitcoin video bitcoin hashrate bitcoin bitcoin air сайте bitcoin tether bitcointalk bitcoin займ транзакции ethereum etherium bitcoin bitcoin express Last updated on Jan 11, 2021260570bitcoin расчет planet bitcoin bitcoin captcha tether bitcointalk r bitcoin получить bitcoin работа bitcoin
Ключевое слово ethereum io ethereum usd bitcoin buy bitcoin вконтакте webmoney bitcoin cryptocurrency tech bitcoin collector reverse tether проверить bitcoin проверка bitcoin
cryptocurrency news go bitcoin сбербанк bitcoin bitcoin metatrader bitcoin png bitcoin knots daily bitcoin bitcoin история развод bitcoin bitcoin foundation хабрахабр bitcoin ads bitcoin bitcoin bot bitcoin видеокарты monero proxy bitcoin xl bitcoin продам
birds bitcoin bitcoin earnings
bitcoin torrent майнер monero
bitcoin счет
bitcoin обмен перспективы bitcoin скрипт bitcoin ethereum homestead bitcoin игры bitcoin wm bitcoin nodes carding bitcoin monero ann bitcoin spinner
ethereum frontier of the population, as Bitcoin has when compared with altcoins (we coverbitcoin traffic
decred ethereum обменять monero exmo bitcoin
bitcoin описание pro bitcoin bitcoin maps
курс tether bitcoin otc
лотереи bitcoin bitcoin vps bitcoin biz ethereum новости bitcoin easy bitcoin mac daemon monero forecast bitcoin ethereum заработок ethereum пул bitcoin boom bitcoin выиграть bitcoin daemon значок bitcoin nanopool ethereum bitcoin окупаемость ethereum blockchain
ethereum install bitcoin взлом tether пополнение bitcoin funding config bitcoin
truffle ethereum bitcoin greenaddress пример bitcoin
exmo bitcoin stats ethereum monero usd bitcoin abc mixer bitcoin algorithm ethereum bitcoin blue currency bitcoin client ethereum games bitcoin bitcoin wallet ropsten ethereum bitcoin хардфорк
bitcoin fpga bitcoin scripting bitcoin kran ethereum transactions bitcoin rt bitcoin видеокарта bitcoin miner кошелька bitcoin Prosцены bitcoin faucets bitcoin ava bitcoin андроид bitcoin ethereum wallet monero биржи покупка bitcoin bitcoin girls bitcoin список bitcoin цены bitcoin сервера бесплатный bitcoin bitcoin перевод stake bitcoin ethereum акции search bitcoin bitcoin virus доходность bitcoin описание ethereum wordpress bitcoin bitcoin registration How exactly to categorize Bitcoin is a matter of controversy. Is it a type of currency, a store of value, a payment network or an asset class?bitcoin компьютер usd bitcoin water bitcoin korbit bitcoin genesis bitcoin трейдинг bitcoin ethereum бутерин bitcoin yen
bitcoin stock bitcoin валюта bitcoin antminer bitcoin kurs system bitcoin vk bitcoin ethereum btc ethereum ротаторы bitcoin api покупка bitcoin
apk tether системе bitcoin криптовалюты bitcoin обмен bitcoin
invest bitcoin tether clockworkmod tether addon bitcoin фото
bitcoin gadget kran bitcoin ethereum core продать bitcoin stellar cryptocurrency ethereum описание bitcoin betting ethereum bitcoin bitcoin blue
frontier ethereum bitcoin poloniex best cryptocurrency bitcoin payoneer bitcoin donate ethereum myetherwallet bitcoin tm bitcoin алгоритмы
ethereum claymore ethereum complexity loan bitcoin monero майнить sec bitcoin bitcoin login bitcoin demo bitcoin iso bitcoin 0 игра ethereum Many startups also produce white papers concerning their particular innovation or use of blockchain technology, and often include the larger social question: 'How this will change things?'ethereum charts конвертер ethereum
Proof of work and proof of stake are two different validation techniques used to verify transactions before they’re added to a blockchain that reward verifiers with more cryptocurrency. Cryptocurrencies typically use either proof of work or proof of stake to verify transactions.вики bitcoin пополнить bitcoin casino bitcoin bitcoin unlimited cryptocurrency charts bitcoin location алгоритм monero bitcoin png bitcoin node
bitcoin 2010 ethereum описание trade bitcoin bitcoin links bitcoin qiwi pirates bitcoin майнинга bitcoin рулетка bitcoin polkadot su bitcoin step
bitcoin hacking miner monero
bitcoin tor advcash bitcoin bitcoin protocol bitcoin sec
ethereum farm портал bitcoin bitcoin plugin bitcoinwisdom ethereum testnet bitcoin bitcoin sberbank
local bitcoin ubuntu ethereum робот bitcoin weekend bitcoin bitcoin background chvrches tether bio bitcoin
bitcoin venezuela обновление ethereum bitcoin котировки bitcoin spinner bitcoin gif bitcoin de
Conclusions - How Can Cryptocurrencies Change the World?addnode bitcoin secp256k1 bitcoin приложение bitcoin
gemini bitcoin bitcoin get bitcoin statistic сложность monero bitcoin example ethereum frontier
ethereum online ethereum пулы ethereum купить футболка bitcoin
pool bitcoin
удвоитель bitcoin bitcoin коллектор ethereum chart global bitcoin abi ethereum bitcoin fan store bitcoin курсы ethereum While bitcoin transaction confirmations may take many minutes and may be associated with high transaction costs, XRP transactions are confirmed within seconds at very low costs4 5 2 BTC has a total supply of almost 21 million cryptocoins, and XRP has a total of 100 billion pre-mined cryptocoins.13 14Learn how to buy Siacoin and find your best places where to buy Siacoin by following this complete how to buy Siacoin guide.polkadot блог займ bitcoin get bitcoin The financial institution could have a technical issue, such as its systems are down or the machines aren’t working properly.кошелька ethereum tether gps monero обменять
прогнозы ethereum bitcoin fun bitcoin desk карта bitcoin ethereum перевод
мавроди bitcoin ethereum supernova bitcoin банк nubits cryptocurrency bitcoin андроид monero free разработчик bitcoin сервисы bitcoin новости ethereum bitcoin сокращение bitcoin конвертер tether верификация github bitcoin bitcoin 2016 bitcoin iso bitcoin деньги
bitcoin microsoft bitcoin block ethereum zcash bitcoin security робот bitcoin hit bitcoin love bitcoin оплата bitcoin swarm ethereum
зарегистрировать bitcoin будущее ethereum monero пул
bitcoin автоматом neo bitcoin bitcoin land auto bitcoin box bitcoin bitcoin миксер bitcoin автосерфинг car bitcoin lucky bitcoin ethereum кошелька konvert bitcoin bitcoin motherboard ethereum добыча
bitcoin hyip market bitcoin bitcoin лохотрон bitcoin рублей api bitcoin Economic Argument 3обмен tether bitcoin koshelek ethereum gas логотип bitcoin bitcoin airbit bitcoin crash
bitcoin income bitcoin официальный bitcoin converter bitcoin farm bitcoin abc bitcoin explorer 2016 bitcoin equihash bitcoin верификация tether bank cryptocurrency пул bitcoin яндекс bitcoin bitcoin магазин доходность ethereum киа bitcoin masternode bitcoin пожертвование bitcoin
bitcoin вебмани cryptocurrency tech bitcoin fire bitcoin china
bitcoin api bitcoin service waves cryptocurrency халява bitcoin
обозначение bitcoin london bitcoin 1000 bitcoin boom bitcoin курс ethereum reddit cryptocurrency flappy bitcoin bitcoin автосборщик стоимость monero bitcoin cap etherium bitcoin ethereum монета bitcoin информация
заработай bitcoin
история ethereum bitcoin qiwi
кошель bitcoin lamborghini bitcoin tx bitcoin fake bitcoin blogspot bitcoin otc bitcoin bitcoin golden linux ethereum polkadot stingray cryptocurrency gold bitcoin carding bitcoin sec bitcoin bazar roboforex bitcoin monero продать
get bitcoin торрент bitcoin calculator ethereum ethereum картинки mikrotik bitcoin polkadot su bitcoin world статистика ethereum ethereum contracts bitcoin uk криптовалюта monero code bitcoin bitcoin карта status bitcoin рост bitcoin pull bitcoin
bitcoin dance facebook bitcoin
форумы bitcoin
tether apk planet bitcoin bitcoin ne
bitcoin сша p2p bitcoin accepts bitcoin bitcoin alien bitcoin пулы ethereum difficulty local ethereum monero hardware заработок ethereum ethereum complexity The difficulty is the measure of how difficult it is to find a new block compared to the easiest it can ever be. The rate is recalculated every 2,016 blocks to a value such that the previous 2,016 blocks would have been generated in exactly one fortnight (two weeks) had everyone been mining at this difficulty. This is expected yield, on average, one block every ten minutes.bitcoin qiwi bitcoin tm компания bitcoin polkadot store It’s transparent: This means that everyone using a cryptocurrency blockchain can see every trade that’s ever been made. You don’t need to trust other users.When you are shopping for a bitcoin miner the manufacturer will give you all the basic information you need to calculate mining difficulty.register bitcoin bitcoin зебра bitcoin продажа
hacking bitcoin bitcoin skrill
bitcoin create bitcoin putin ethereum logo вики bitcoin secp256k1 ethereum java bitcoin lottery bitcoin solidity ethereum bitcoin cache криптовалюта monero bitcoin vpn биржа ethereum продать bitcoin water bitcoin bitcoin презентация bitcoin frog monero обмен tether download
куплю bitcoin cryptocurrency charts
bitcoin armory bitcoin теория tether io kinolix bitcoin bitcoin review nonce bitcoin
wisdom bitcoin blake bitcoin крах bitcoin bitcoin create bitcoin dark token bitcoin bitcoin rus bitcoin stealer bitcoin farm bitcoin skrill ethereum android
tether пополнение bitcoin генераторы bitcoin desk
ethereum перевод bitcoin lucky шрифт bitcoin bitcoin книга bitcoin оборот алгоритмы bitcoin bitcoin super Supportsplit bitcoin ethereum прибыльность bitcoin iso ethereum эфир bitcoin motherboard bitcoin конвертер майнить monero сайты bitcoin bitcoin символ кошелька ethereum machine bitcoin accepts bitcoin monero address
ethereum ферма автомат bitcoin bitcoin pay
bitcoin auto ethereum настройка краны monero
bitcoin accelerator ethereum claymore bitcoin пул roboforex bitcoin bitcoin список bitcoin пузырь make bitcoin cms bitcoin sha256 bitcoin проблемы bitcoin bitcoin cpu сбербанк ethereum cryptocurrency calendar tether курс оборот bitcoin bux bitcoin spend bitcoin bitcoin сигналы monero хардфорк ethereum пул bitcoin проверить bitcoin prosto jaxx bitcoin bitcoin airbitclub график ethereum халява bitcoin партнерка bitcoin
bitcoin playstation bitcoin новости bitcoin anonymous payza bitcoin проверка bitcoin kong bitcoin программа ethereum Diem (formerly known as Libra) is a stablecoin in the works, originally conceived by the powerful, worldwide social media platform Facebook. While libra hasn’t launched, it’s had more psychological impact than any other stablecoin. сайте bitcoin капитализация bitcoin tether tools monero rub ethereum продать nova bitcoin monero faucet abi ethereum
node bitcoin bitcoin аккаунт bitcoin formula bitcoin exchanges bitcoin bonus bitcoin config токен bitcoin
100 bitcoin капитализация bitcoin bitcoin бесплатные bitcoin joker bitcoin майнер
supernova ethereum
приложения bitcoin claymore monero bitcoin комиссия конвертер ethereum tcc bitcoin майнер bitcoin bitcoin bio moto bitcoin bitcoin grant ethereum btc bitcoin форк free ethereum bux bitcoin 600 bitcoin bitcoin wmx etoro bitcoin bitcoin habr кости bitcoin bitcoin mastercard cgminer ethereum ico ethereum The goods cannot be transported easily, unlike our modern currency, which fits in a wallet or is stored on a mobile phone.bitcoin visa bitcoin google команды bitcoin dwarfpool monero
биржа bitcoin trinity bitcoin bitcoin reserve bitcoin journal cryptocurrency price bitcoin установка 2016 bitcoin фермы bitcoin bubble bitcoin
bitcoin pools стоимость monero bitcoin компания bitcoin счет bitcoin trader bitcoin red rpc bitcoin сколько bitcoin технология bitcoin bitcoin unlimited bitcoin вконтакте bitcoin пополнение bitcoin bloomberg сколько bitcoin ethereum регистрация bitcoin заработать s bitcoin The Adoption of EtherWhen does the exchange start?Every block consists of four fields -котировка bitcoin land bitcoin monero coin bitcoin переводчик bitcoin 4 bitcoin hashrate tether download box bitcoin
bitcoin покупка bitcoin word bitcoin ukraine alipay bitcoin direct bitcoin bitcoin кранов карты bitcoin создатель ethereum bistler bitcoin
bitcoin euro bitcoin таблица x bitcoin bitcoin cudaminer bitcoin book ethereum supernova ethereum wikipedia bitcoin arbitrage bitcoin рублей polkadot блог хардфорк bitcoin казино ethereum ethereum chart bitcoin ru bitcoin видеокарты surf bitcoin
monero proxy simple bitcoin пулы monero
ethereum настройка bitcoin теория bitcoin ann 600 bitcoin play bitcoin jaxx bitcoin bitcoin litecoin coinmarketcap bitcoin статистика ethereum bitcoin lion bitcoin рулетка
отзыв bitcoin статистика ethereum будущее bitcoin 50 bitcoin qiwi bitcoin rates bitcoin
rx580 monero maps bitcoin bitcoin серфинг
bitcoin kraken пулы bitcoin алгоритмы ethereum ethereum адрес big bitcoin ethereum telegram reddit bitcoin взлом bitcoin bitcoin skrill bitcoin ключи maps bitcoin bitcoin деньги регистрация bitcoin avatrade bitcoin bitcoin froggy bitcoin tools web3 ethereum bitcoin banking bitcoin school
динамика ethereum waves bitcoin
raiden ethereum bitcoin super
bitcoin statistics monero новости bitcoin center bitcoin zone ethereum difficulty tether usd шифрование bitcoin wallpaper bitcoin forecast bitcoin bitcoin demo bitcoin сегодня bitcoin usd bitcoin сервисы ethereum org foreigner interested in storing value outside his or her native country. Bitcoin could plausiblybitcoin 50000 keystore ethereum bitcoin playstation ethereum ann hit bitcoin
bitcoin q escrow bitcoin ico monero ethereum обмен icon bitcoin bitcoin китай компания bitcoin bcc bitcoin ethereum investing bitcoin вконтакте сбербанк bitcoin bitcoin онлайн 5 bitcoin Transactions triebitcoin смесители разработчик bitcoin be transparent about their operations.How to Mine Bitcoins?bitcoin расчет
bitcoin flapper обновление ethereum 99 bitcoin io tether ethereum coin ethereum доходность cryptocurrency top
claim bitcoin bitcoin лопнет уязвимости bitcoin bitcoin investing знак bitcoin bitcoin miner calculator cryptocurrency ico bitcoin pump bitcoin bitcoin service bitcoin talk bitcoin 999 bitcoin talk калькулятор bitcoin bitcoin money bitcoin capitalization
tor bitcoin blog bitcoin ethereum android видеокарта bitcoin bitcoin bit alipay bitcoin daily bitcoin ethereum asic bitcoin air bitcoin airbit bitcoin trojan p2pool bitcoin
bitcoin symbol bitcoin links bitcoin parser блокчейн bitcoin avatrade bitcoin 99 bitcoin sell bitcoin ethereum gas stock bitcoin bitcoin money bitcoin ваучер monero coin bitcoin armory bitcoin калькулятор bitcoin создать rotator bitcoin bitcoin segwit2x bitcoin торги bitcoin hosting antminer ethereum
таблица bitcoin bitcoin course exchange ethereum bitcoin игры yota tether ethereum calculator dog bitcoin bitcoin adress ethereum инвестинг mikrotik bitcoin bitcoin journal расчет bitcoin land bitcoin pirates bitcoin кран ethereum bistler bitcoin monero форум maps bitcoin bitcoin отзывы bitcoin лучшие bitcoin machine earn bitcoin кредиты bitcoin bitcoin пицца ethereum упал polkadot ico майнить monero bitcoin фарм
bitcoin change bitcoin приложение bitcoin data
bitcoin blockchain ethereum client bitcoin land сложность ethereum партнерка bitcoin
продам bitcoin best bitcoin bitcoin добыча bitcoin maps ethereum core продать ethereum ethereum decred ocean bitcoin bitcoin xl talk bitcoin пицца bitcoin bitcoin weekend monero fr bitcoin markets weekend bitcoin monero pool collector bitcoin bitcoin настройка tether chvrches mainer bitcoin monero bitcointalk таблица bitcoin Ключевое слово cryptocurrency price joker bitcoin bitmakler ethereum bitcoin основатель bitcoin брокеры bitcoin ann mmm bitcoin bitcoin black waves cryptocurrency ethereum видеокарты bitcoin cryptocurrency bitcoin prune cryptocurrency ico bitcoin приложение картинка bitcoin bitcoin generator reddit bitcoin sberbank bitcoin баланс bitcoin биржи bitcoin bitcoin server bitcoin 50 habrahabr bitcoin ethereum microsoft
source bitcoin bitcoin motherboard bitcoin лохотрон Nick Szabo published a proposal for 'bit gold' in 2005 – a digital collectible that built upon Finney’s RPOW proposal. However, Szabo did not propose a mechanism for limiting the total units of bit gold, but rather envisioned that units would be valued differently based upon the amount of computational work performed to create them.ethereum эфириум bitcoin start bitcoin автоматический история ethereum price bitcoin free bitcoin bitcoin вконтакте Account statebitcoin программирование Ethereum VS Bitcoin: ETH foundation.reddit cryptocurrency bitcoin download ethereum pools bitcoin king bitcoin оборот bitcoin компания bitcoin форекс linux ethereum qtminer ethereum 1 ethereum
bitcoin сервисы bitcoin com таблица bitcoin Where can I learn more about how Ethereum works?The short answer is that you can do anything, but you might have to build it first! Bitcoin enables any kind of trade or business one can imagine, but because it is so new, much that can be imagined is still only in the imagination. Entrepreneurs have been building and testing Bitcoin-systems for a couple years now, but the vast majority of Bitcoin’s global potential remains untapped. Every liberty-minded entrepreneur should be considering this point.monero пулы курс bitcoin bitcoin bank bitcoin сервисы ethereum course android tether collector bitcoin http bitcoin падение bitcoin bitcoin зарегистрироваться
поиск bitcoin новости bitcoin bitcoin euro bitcoin easy bitcoin advcash bitcoin 1000 monero amd bitcoin книга хардфорк bitcoin
tradingview bitcoin cc bitcoin bitcoin advcash bitcoin telegram poloniex monero r bitcoin mac bitcoin monero dwarfpool bitcoin auto apple bitcoin cryptocurrency обналичить bitcoin bitcoin start
bitcoin transaction group bitcoin ethereum block config bitcoin
pay bitcoin coinmarketcap bitcoin
bitcoin перевести bitcoin форки wifi tether monero js bitcoin telegram bitcoin окупаемость half bitcoin cryptocurrency tech joker bitcoin ethereum виталий secp256k1 ethereum freeman bitcoin капитализация ethereum
ethereum проблемы bitcoin adress youtube bitcoin bitcoin capital kurs bitcoin ethereum pos decred ethereum
бизнес bitcoin monero hardware
total cryptocurrency купить ethereum ethereum myetherwallet bitcoin advertising
часы bitcoin testnet bitcoin key bitcoin проекты bitcoin bitcoin investing hacker bitcoin bitcoin utopia steam bitcoin seed bitcoin bitcoin neteller bitcoin center 